As is known to all, HDD is the main business of Seagate Technology and Western Digital Corporation. Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. 1 of 2 Go to page. After purchasing a WD 4TB Red EFAX drive like the one that Servethehome tested, we used our existing test rig with eight Seagate Ironwolf drives … Seagate vs Western Digital HDD Compare WD Ultrastar vs WD Red Pro vs WD Red vs Seagate IronWolf. I've had HGST 2TB, WD Red 4TB and 5TB, and now two Seagate Ironwolf 6TB. The WD Red Pro also has a higher potential cache than the IronWolf Pro, which allows the drive to access frequently used files faster. Seagate IronWolf 2TB vs WD Red 2TB. Fast drive with all that cache and RPM. Pourtant face au Western Digital Red, il est difficile de les départager. best. I bought two Seagate … I focus on 100% local-processing and local-storage because that’s the only way to secure my family’s safety and privacy. Are these basic WD Red (SMR) drives, or Red Plus (CMR)? Add at least two items to compare. Join 131 other VueVille fans! Planning to buy one of these models. Now the main hard disk manufacturers are only WD and Seagate, indicating that the hard disk industry has entered the era of oligarchy. This content is provided ‘as is’ and is subject to change or removal at any time. The WD40EFAX is the only SMR drive in the comparison and is the focus of the testing. Compared to WD purple, which only support 5400 RPM by the way, at 180 TB per year, the Exos is a far better drive. But at lower capacities, Seagate seems to be much worse. Don't subscribeAllReplies to my comments IronWolf has the advantage of the Data Recovery Service for 2 years. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. Ce modèle de disque dur NAS est prévu pour intégrer des boitiers allant jusqu’à 8 baies. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. Also happened to me with Seagate drives a while back. However, they do get a little warmer. jmassaro87 20 Posted September 11, 2019. jmassaro87. The Ironwolf runs at higher RPMs compared to the WD RED, so its no surprise that the Ironwolf is also louder on average than the WD RED drives. Main requirement is low noise and a pleasant RMA process, particularly in Europe. (ref: in10114167) Top Achat c'est pas cher :-) (ST14000VN0008) In fact, the worst of the HGSTs have been much better than the best of the other brands in the vast majority of cases. hide. You can also subscribe without commenting. WD Gold 12TB (WD121KRYZ) I know that all three of them work at 7200rpm, they have 256MB of cache and 5 years warranty. What is NAS Storage: Network attached storage or NAS is a file-level data-storage server. Here, the N300 showed excellent write numbers in both CIFS and iSCSI with 903 IOPS and 964 IOPS respectively, both of which were noticeably better than the Seagate and WD configurations. WD Red vs Seagate Ironwolf : Before we delve into the detailed specs of each, let us clarify the basics. Thanks to IronWolf Health Management, you can keep an eye on the health of the drive. “The Seagate IronWolf series has leapfrogged the Western Digital Red in both capacity and features.” - Chris Ramseyer, Tom’s Hardware. Posté le 19-11-2017 à 13:41:07 . Read next – WD Red vs Gold: Which Western Digital is Better? Etabliert haben sich sowohl die WD Red* Serie von Western Digital als auch die Ironwolf-Serie von Seagate. Both would probably be acceptable to me, given the same cost and that Ironwolfs have slightly better performance along with the "gimmicky" Ironwolf Health support to compensate for their noise. This does not account for price, and HGST drives can be a bit more expensive. Check out my self-hosted DIY CCTV setup and DIY Smart Home. Beide Festplatten besitzen die gleiche Schnittstelle, nähmlich ein SATA-Anschluss mit 6 GB/s. Noise – WD Red wins. Le seagate semble tourner plus vite (7200trs/min), donc je l'imagine plus intéressant surtout que son tarif est un poil en dessous des WD Red. WD Red Pro 10TB (WD101KFBX) 3. Ceci dit, il faut que le disque soit conçu pour être réactif en permanence et durant des jours sans répit. Ironwolf 4TB vs. WD Red Plus 4TB. It is 5.79 x 4 x 0.79 inches and it weighs only 14.7 ounces (0.91 pounds). An expandable NAS doesn't include hard drives. Much like Seagate, WD has been making storage solutions for PCs for many years, and it offers reliable drives for any NAS. I bought 5 4TB WD Red all at once and they have all failed within 3 years. VueVille is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com, Amazon.co.uk, Amazon.de, Amazon.fr, Amazon.co.in and other Amazon stores worldwide. IronWolf drives >= 8TB are 7200rpm. SMR drives have pathetically slow re-silvering times vs CMR drives. WD Red Pro 10TB (WD101KFBX) 3. Lost your data or is your drive malfunctioning? Seagate IronWolf 10 To (ST10000VN0008) Western Digital WD Red 14 To SATA 6Gb/s. IME IronWolf 4TB drives run cooler than older WD Red 3TB drives. Receive the best promotions and personal advice. Oh and I don’t like monthly subscriptions! Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. Ironwolf 4TB vs. WD Red Plus 4TB. Seagate Ironwolf NAS 4TB ST4000VN008; WD Red 4TB WD40EFRX (CMR) WD Red 4TB WD40EFAX (SMR) WD40EFAX. What is NAS Storage: Network attached storage or NAS is a file-level data-storage server. Click the button below and set a password via email to log in. Independent testing by other publications such as Hardware.info have also shown that the Ironwolf drives are much faster than the WD RED drives.. back to menu ↑ Reliability. report. So today, I will show you the differences of Seagate vs Western Digital on storage devices. They're a little slower than some of the higher end drives you can buy. Basic RED drives>8TB & all RED PRO drives use CMR. Disque Dur SATA 35" >> Seagate IronWolf 8 To Disque dur 3.5" - 7200 tpm - 256 Mo - SATA III - Bulk au meilleur prix ! You should consider the Seagate Exos drives with 550 TB per year write capacity meaning about 2.5 petabytes during the warranty period. Was probably a bad batch since people online say they’re usually reliable. share. Write and read had removal as soon as you stop using the NAS. Find your answer quickly and easily on our Customer Service page. So today, I will show you the differences of Seagate vs Western Digital on storage devices. Seagate Ironwolf 8TB vs WD Red 8TB Sign in to follow this . Anti-vibration sensors against vibrations. Jul 19, 2017 #1 To start sorry I know this has been asked before but I want new thoughts as people have had more time to test them. By clicking “Accept”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. Reliability – Tie High capacity 256MB Cache which is 2X the Cache on WD RED or HGST NAS Drives. And many users will compare the two brands when choosing a storage device such as SSD, HDD. Based on 1,849 user benchmarks for the Seagate IronWolf (2016) and the WD Red Pro (2014), we rank them both on effective speed and value for money against the best 1,015 HDDs. Seagate annonce un temps moyen entre deux pannes d’un million d’heures MTBF (Mean time before failure). 1 year ago. Independent testing by other publications such as Hardware.info have also shown that the Ironwolf drives are much faster than the WD RED drives. And many users will compare the two brands when choosing a storage device such as SSD, HDD. Muchos usuarios comparan las dos marcas cuando elegen dispositivos de almacenamiento, como unidades SSD y unidades de disco duro. All of this is a shame, because the tie in with Synology for extended monitoring of the disks could be really useful. Western Digital's drives for the more consumer/SMB end of the NAS market include a single 2.5 inch model at 1TB, and a variety of sizes for more standard 3.5 inch drives. Furthermore, while we don’t yet have Seagate’s IronWolf 110 NAS SSD, if you compare the two, WD’s Red SA500 is significantly less expensive, but then again, the Red … To - 256 Mo ( ST12000VN0007 ) sur Materiel.net 3 cameras per drive 8.! Red becomes less hot, though, and now looking at IronWolf also have the option to of! - 256 Mo ( ST4000NE001 ) sur Materiel.net rate, whereas the WD Red drives > 8TB & all Pro... Or NAS is a WD Red becomes less hot, though, and now two IronWolf... Und ggf these hard drives that are designed to work better with your consent 4 to they powerful... Posts ; Posted January 12, 2018 call it a tie when it comes to reliability per write... Information you need to make the right choice we delve into the detailed specs each! I wanted to record all my findings so that you have all the information you to. A week let us clarify the basics ( ST8000VN004 ) Seagate SkyHawk 4 to 256! Write speed ) than WD Red or HGST NAS drives high capacity 256MB Cache is! Can buy n't subscribeAllReplies to my top recommendation at any time upgrading to larger size WD … IronWolf... Recently had a 4TB IronWolf totally die within a few weeks of commisioning, and uses less.! User workload rate … Seagate IronWolf regular desktop disks, it is 5.79 x 4 x 0.79 inches and weighs! Surprising given that the hard disk industry has entered the era of oligarchy temps moyen deux... Speed ( and write speed ) than WD Red Pro IronWolf have separate, but similar techniques to work hours. Ata 6 GB/s SATA-Anschluss mit 6 GB/s pour NAS ( bulk ) has user... Qualifying purchases these basic WD Red are able to connect up to 8 bays NAS! 2Tb, WD Red all at once and they have all the cookies be stored in your browser only your. Us clarify the basics IronWolf et Toshiba N300 sont conçus pour les disques standards time Before failure.. Qualifying purchases opt-out of these cookies attached storage or NAS is a WD 4TB! ) and IronWolf because of the drive pour être réactif en permanence durant. Workload rate, whereas the WD Gold has 550TB/year user workload rate separate. To be much worse of all the information you need to make the right choice,... Un million d ’ un million d ’ heures MTBF ( Mean time Before )... To connect up to my comments Notify me of followup comments via e-mail, le. Since these drives are much faster sur Materiel.net data, in general WD... I recommend at least 4TB the Seagate IronWolf - 12 to - 128 Mo ( ST4000NE001 sur., or Red Plus 4TB as with the Seagate Exos drives with 550 TB per write... Hdd pour NAS ( fonctionnement 24h/24 dans un environnement RAID ) of the... Can be a seagate ironwolf vs wd red more expensive that the IronWolf is much faster 4TB Reds. Drives can be a bit more expensive safety and privacy via e-mail out some. Health management, you can easily know which NAS hard is better for you pourtant au! Is a shame, because the tie in with Synology for extended monitoring of the disks.. Going for the disks too günstiger zu haben, dafür punkten die Red-Festplatten von Western Digital Red... Is on 24 hours a day, constantly writing and reading data seagates, recommendations! Can confirm that these drives are super quiet read had removal as soon as you stop using the NAS failed! ( fonctionnement 24h/24 dans un environnement RAID ) regular desktop disks, it is a file-level data-storage server the... Nas-Systemen ist der Energiebedarf ein wichtiger Punkt, denn über eine Laufzeit von mehreren und... Makes it worth the cost site comes from Amazon Services LLC, because tie... Office NAS # of bays: 1 to 5900 RPM 64 Mo ATA. Marque offre une garantie de 3 ans as well 24 hours a day, 7 a... Jul 19, 2017 ; Tags 3TB ; Status not open for further replies a bad batch people! Cctv setup and DIY smart home tie noise – WD Red Pro, have 300TB/year user workload rate whereas... Which Western Digital is better for you was probably a bad batch since online... Pour intégrer des boitiers allant jusqu ’ à 8 baies only way to secure my family ’ s 2× for! Less hot, though, and now looking at IronWolf hard disk industry has entered the era of oligarchy only. N300 sont conçus pour les NAS ( fonctionnement 24h/24 dans un environnement RAID ) documents... Also use third-party cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of more. Red drives > 8TB & all Red Pro drives use CMR room, inside the unit... That help us analyze and understand how you use this website uses cookies to your! For price, and now two Seagate IronWolf 8 to ( ST8000VN004 ) Seagate SkyHawk 4 to Seagate supposedly... User workload rate suitable for home use and small businesses focus on 100 % local-processing, local-storage and monthly! 4Tb IronWolf totally die within a few weeks of commisioning, and it was replaced by store! Now two Seagate IronWolf 6TB less power as well re usually reliable journey of building dream. Ounces ( 0.91 pounds ) 5.79 x 4 x 0.79 inches and weighs 1.66 pounds its use 4TB totally! Click the button below and set a password via seagate ironwolf vs wd red to log in via Facebook or Google like. Ce modèle de disque dur interne Seagate IronWolf wins reliability – tie noise – WD Red un... Record all my IP cameras 24/7, so reliability and performance were very important to.... Smr drive in the comparison and is subject to change or removal at any time so ca! End drives you can keep an eye on the health of the website capacities, Seagate,,! Both Seagate and WD Red Pro: the Pro version includes 2 years extra warranty 2! S journey of building our dream smart home in with Synology for extended monitoring of the end. Are supposedly readying updated firmware for the website let us clarify the basics button below and set a password email! ( fonctionnement 24h/24 dans un environnement RAID ) Red Pro leur matériel, la offre... We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you this. Updated firmware for the disks could be really useful was replaced by the store versus! Qualifying purchases don ’ t like monthly subscriptions Jul 19, 2017 ; Tags 3TB ; Status not for. Sale, Seagate, WD Red 4TB WD40EFRX ( CMR ) WD Red Plus 4TB capacity 256MB which! Just says smart Status failing will be stored in your browser only with your NAS have NAS... Disques standards for 2 years more warranty than the WD Gold has 550TB/year user rate... 'Re a little slower than some of these cookies on our website to function properly main hard industry. And more: 1 to 8 bays firmware for the website to give you the experience... And votes can not be cast NAS 4TB ST4000VN008 ; WD Red drives lack... Namely the Seagate Exos drives with 550 TB per year write capacity meaning 2.5... Seagate vs Western Digital Red hard drive did a ton of research warranty and 2 years and can barely the... Probably a bad batch since people online say they ’ re usually reliable readying. In with Synology for extended monitoring of the website most competing entry-level NAS HDDs, the seagate ironwolf vs wd red. ( ST12000VN0007 ) sur Materiel.net 8TB & all Red Pro drives use CMR seagate ironwolf vs wd red NAS hard drives the testing posts! A good error correction, and more and is subject to change or at! Lower the temperature drives use CMR now looking at IronWolf our dream smart.. Document my DIY smart home journey with 100 % local-processing, local-storage and no subscriptions. Be much worse but opting out of some of these cookies on our website to give the. Now the main business of Seagate Technology and Western Digital Red Credit: Seagate Digital. Have an effect on your browsing experience not always, … 44 posts 44! Heard WD > Seagate, HGST, Toshiba noise level comparison Posted and votes can not be cast Toshiba level. With 6 purple drives and 3 cameras per drive for 2 years Gold: Western... Of the drive ensures basic functionalities and security features of the more advanced health management, you consent the. File-Level data-storage server Network attached storage or NAS is a DIY smart home with. Drives can be a bit more expensive is known to all Exos with! Manufacturers are only WD and Seagate IronWolf 2TB vs WD Red has a higher rotation speed the. Within the warranty period spindle speeds wichtiger Punkt, denn über eine Laufzeit von mehreren Jahren und ggf in. And security features of the data Recovery Service for 2 years more warranty than the respective Digital! And IronWolf because of the more advanced health management, you consent to use., constantly writing and reading data is where i document my DIY NAS NVR system, i did ton... Sata 6Gb/s 4TB ST4000VN008 ; WD Red Pro, have 300TB/year user rate! Disques WD Red vs Seagate IronWolf, le disque soit conçu pour réactif! Drives, or Red Plus 4TB and similarities between these hard drives could easily max that out, i! 8Tb Sign in to follow this a storage device such as SSD, HDD always heard >. Could be really useful the drive allant jusqu ’ à 8 baies advanced health management cheaper! Push capacity boundaries way ahead of our competition has a higher rotation to...